Shortlist vs. Traditional Recruiters

You don't need a $15,000 recruiter to hire a great SDR. Here's the full comparison.

Factor Shortlist Traditional Recruiters
Cost per hire ✅ Free (pilot) / $199/mo $12,000–$25,000 (20% of salary)
Time to first candidates ✅ 48 hours 3–6 weeks
Candidates delivered ✅ 5 pre-vetted, scored 3–5 CVs, minimal screening
Match scoring ✅ AI-scored on 7 SDR criteria Gut feeling / keyword match
Contract required ✅ No Yes — 30–60 day exclusivity typical
Placement guarantee ✅ Unlimited reruns 90-day replacement (maybe)
Specialization ✅ SDR/BDR only Generalist (SDR is one of 50+ roles)
Transparency ✅ Full scores + reasoning Black box
Our Verdict Recruiters made sense in 2005 when sourcing was hard. AI has commoditized SDR sourcing. Pay for results, not relationships.

See the difference yourself

Post your SDR role and get 5 AI-matched candidates in 48 hours. Free to start.

Try Shortlist free — 5 candidates in 48 hours